POG Politics Thread Version 3

POG Politics Thread Version 3

Come on in! Since Dustin is taking his ball and going home, it's time to start a new politics thread.

17 September 2020 at 09:34 PM
Reply...

782 Replies

i
a

by TBobLP P

filthy, trying to convince somebody to give up a hierarchical view of society and who deserves what is never going to happen. Mark and his family have theirs, he believes its because they deserve it, and that means there must be some people out there who don't deserve it. whatever reason and logic you want to use wont apply, because it doesnt appeal to the "pick yourself up by your bootstraps" crowd.

Yes, a lot of that is true. However, there is never a proposed workable solution.

My gut tells me what we have now is probably as close to optimal that we are ever going to get.


by Mark_K P

Yes, a lot of that is true. However, there is never a proposed workable solution.

My gut tells me what we have now is probably as close to optimal that we are ever going to get.

don't we currently have better systems right now? dozens of them?

in happiness polls, usa, the leader of our current system, ranks pretty low. the happier countries tend to have financial floors, so people aren't living on the streets and starving.

and of course probably 99.999999% of the years in human history, we've lived in better societies than we do now. im sure you disagree though. im guessing you'd think we are much better off than pre history societies where we had lifespan of 25 or whatever, and infant mortality of like 50% or whatever... and you might be right about that. but you might also be biased because you live a happy life. you seem like a really happy guy. and good for you! seriously. it makes me feel good to think of you happy

but maybe for you it makes it harder to understand the misery of our times. like people are killing themselves like crazy. taking tons of drugs. something like 60% or whatever of the world's drugs are consumed in USA, and we are 5% of the population!

the anxiety in our society is off the charts. depression too. the capitalist internet is really damaging us. and i point out that capitalist part, becuase that's what makes the internet so damaging. driven by profit we just let the algorithms dictate everything, and extremism gets views, so people become more extreme... and photoshopped unrealistic girls get views on intsa, so real life girls compare to themselves and are miserable... and on and on


How many of those things are true?


Filthy, I just don't see much doom and gloom. Family, friends associates... Everyone has their personal battles but overall are living and enjoying life!

idk dude, that's a serious black cloud around you. Life shouldn't be that negative.


by pwnsall P

How many of those things are true?

gotta be at least 50% 😆


https://forsocialchange.org/direct-givin...

Direct giving is routinely shown to be one of the most effective ways to lift people out of poverty.

If you did this on a massive scale it would be hugely transformatory

And i dont see how elon musk selling shares in twitter so he can achieve this is any different. Didnt he sell like 25% of tesla and nothing changed?


Also- wealth inequality is proven to do make societies more unstable. This is obv bad

Second, i struggle with the idea that someone having billions or millions in cash whilst others starve is any way a society people would chose. So its generically level 1 bad.
There may be some reasons on top of this that taking their money is also bad, but, if you have a world where there are only two people and one person is starving and another dancing in liquid gold thats obviously a bad society.


by Mark_K P

If you look at the global economy, if you take those 10 billionaires and distribute all their money to the lower 25% of the worlds population, what medium/long term difference would it make? Small - none?.

I assume the catastrophic effect of removing all that locked equity from those 10-20ish companies would be far more damaging.

Explain how making the majority owners of the top 10 companies would be really damaging


More interesting is which viewpoints of substance does one think reasonable people can disagree on than those that are prederided for being evil or stupid.


by pwnsall P

More interesting is which viewpoints of substance does one think reasonable people can disagree on than those that are prederided for being evil or stupid.

Well its definitely not ice cream flavours


did you guys hear how there is a plot to have taylor swift date kelce and get KC to the super bowl, so that tswizzle can endorse joe biden?


by filthyvermin P

did you guys hear how there is a plot to have taylor swift date kelce and get KC to the super bowl, so that tswizzle can endorse joe biden?

🙄


Who's more foolish, the fool who believes there is a plot to get tswift to endorse Biden at the super bowl or the fool who believes people believe there is a plot to get tswift to endorse Biden at the super bowl?


On that note I've seen more mention recently making fun of people who believe there is a chip in the covid vaccine but I've never met anyone who actually believes that specific conspiracy.


remember in past elections when birdman was asking "what would a democrat have to do for you to stop supporting them as the lesser of two evils?"?

i wonder if genocide is enough for those of you who vote for dems. are you still gonna vote for genocide joe, just to beat trump?


by filthyvermin P

i wonder if genocide is enough for those of you who vote for dems. are you still gonna vote for genocide joe, just to beat trump?

This wasn’t your question but I would like to assure you and the rest of the world that the ongoing misuse of the word genocide, while irritating, does not frost my cheerios sufficiently to get me to ever vote for Trump.

Of course I’ll never vote for Biden either but his position on Gaza has nothing to do with that.


semantics aside(if that word means what i think it means), 11k dead kids, 19k made orphans, stealing a country... if you can vote for a guy who does this, then i don't even know man


Someone retweeted this into my timeline and not going to lie, I lol’d.


I've seen the people are mad about tswift thing get more play lately. When some thread asks what's going on with tswift there is never a top answer that says it's fake news.

Psy op!?!?


by Doctor Zeus P

https://forsocialchange.org/direct-givin...

Direct giving is routinely shown to be one of the most effective ways to lift people out of poverty.

If you did this on a massive scale it would be hugely transformatory

And i dont see how elon musk selling shares in twitter so he can achieve this is any different. Didnt he sell like 25% of tesla and nothing chang

I hadn't really read this but assumed the link was going to be a study not some weird website just pushing its case.

And this sentence was really weird to me

"Further, research has found that cash transfers do not increase spending on goods, such as alcohol, tobacco and drugs."

Also they only mention qualified recipients.

Utah gave houses to homeless for a minute and it seemed to work ok.


lol


by filthyvermin P


generally though, im thinking more and more that computers, ai, social media... it's all making the world a worse place to live.

driving on freeways, walking on cement in between skyscrapers, crowded in by millions of people, 0 connection with our food and shelter. minimal connection with our villages.

most of us have more of a connection with our boss, or some random celeb, or fictional character, than we do with our cousins, aunts, uncles,

Forget transmitting, printing, scribing, counting... follow the scent of game on the wind, die young and strong, and probably in excruciating pain.


by filthyvermin P

the problem is we don't own what we produce

Maybe the problem is that we do.


by filthyvermin P


and hopefully 8 billion people collectively deciding the fate of the planet would decide to save it for our children and grand children, and all the other animals and plants.

because the handful of people deciding the fate of our planet have decided to destroy it.

Again, the problem is the opposite, I think.

Too many influencers are pulling in too many inconsistent directions, but since we really don't want to see how many orders of magnitude we're willing to tolerate in terms of vaporized humans, we kind of have to let them.


by filthyvermin P

the capitalist internet is really damaging us. and i point out that capitalist part, becuase that's what makes the internet so damaging. driven by profit

we just let the algorithms dictate everything, and extremism gets views, so people become more extreme... and photoshopped unrealistic girls get views on intsa, so real life girls compare to themselves and are miserable... and on and on

Yes, the "we're just a platform" argument is bullshit. They aren't just hosting; they're directing.


by Mark_K P

Filthy, I just don't see much doom and gloom. Family, friends associates... Everyone has their personal battles but overall are living and enjoying life!

idk dude, that's a serious black cloud around you. Life shouldn't be that negative.

You may consider getting out more - visit the capital city of just about any state.


Reply...